Joe Cole Shot and Killed by Anthony Agnew

A series of newspaper and court documents recording the shooting of African-American resident of Lauderdale County Joe Cole by Florence African-American resident Anthony Agnew in January of 1902. <br /><br />the 41 year-old Cole, an employee of GW Pruitt was shot one mile East of Florenc...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Format:	Electronic
Published:	Project Say Something: The Shoals Black History Collection
Subjects:	Photographs, documents, and clippings
Online Access:	https://shoalsblackhistory.omeka.net/items/show/1256

format	Electronic
collection	The Law, Crime and Punishment Collection
building	Project Say Something: The Shoals Black History Collection
publisher	Project Say Something: The Shoals Black History Collection
topic	Photographs, documents, and clippings
spellingShingle	Photographs, documents, and clippings Joe Cole Shot and Killed by Anthony Agnew
fulltopic	Photographs, documents, and clippings The Law, Crime and Punishment
description	A series of newspaper and court documents recording the shooting of African-American resident of Lauderdale County Joe Cole by Florence African-American resident Anthony Agnew in January of 1902. <br /><br />the 41 year-old Cole, an employee of GW Pruitt was shot one mile East of Florence on the Waterloo Road while driving his wagon back from Florence, where he had been to sell a load of cotton, to Rhodesville, in West Lauderdale County, and instantly killed. <br /><br />Local resident Mark Haley discovered Cole's body riddled with slugs and buckshot, lying facedown in the road at about 3 o'clock that afternoon. Cole had been shot above the waist on his left side and in the head. Cole's team of horses apparently kept heading towards Rhodesville. <br /><br />At 8 pm Lauderdale County Sheriff OB Hill headed to the scene of the crime with bloodhounds from Tuscumbia, in Colbert County, and tracked one Anthony Agnew, 49 years old, to Koger Island, in the TN River; clues at Koger Island led Sheriff Hill to Baldwin, Mississippi, where, five days after the alleged murder, Agnew was captured on Sunday and remanded to jail. <br /><br />After a preliminary hearing before Justice McPeters Agnew was bound over to the grand jury without bail. He was tried in Florence in late March. <br /><br />Agnew was defended by RT Simpson, Jr. and George P. Jones, with WH Sawtelle and Cecil A. Beasley prosecuting. <br /><br />In the FOUR-DAY trial it was alleged that Agnew shot Cole because the married Cole was planning to run away with Agnew's wife, thus Agnew ambushed Cole from a blind along a wire fence on Waterloo Road, however the jury was hung, with six jurors voting "guilty" and six voting "not guilty."<br /><br />Agnew's second trial was held in September of 1902 and this time the jury found him "not guilty."<br /><br />Joseph "Joe" Cole (ca. 1861-1902), who had a "fair reputation" locally, was married to a woman named Bettie Cantrell (ca. 1862-1952) with two children. Joe was a farmer living at Gravelly Springs, near Rhodesville, in 1900.<br /><br />Oakland (near Rhodesville in Lauderdale County) resident and Baldwin, Mississippi native Anthony Agnew (ca. 1853-), said to be "a very superior negro" with an "excellent reputation," was married to a woman named Fannie and the couple had a total of 12 children, two of which had died by 1900.
title	Joe Cole Shot and Killed by Anthony Agnew
titleStr	Joe Cole Shot and Killed by Anthony Agnew
id	PSSlaw1256
url	https://shoalsblackhistory.omeka.net/items/show/1256
_version_	1799683126855729152
spelling	Joe Cole Shot and Killed by Anthony AgnewThe Law, Crime and PunishmentA series of newspaper and court documents recording the shooting of African-American resident of Lauderdale County Joe Cole by Florence African-American resident Anthony Agnew in January of 1902. <br /><br />the 41 year-old Cole, an employee of GW Pruitt was shot one mile East of Florence on the Waterloo Road while driving his wagon back from Florence, where he had been to sell a load of cotton, to Rhodesville, in West Lauderdale County, and instantly killed. <br /><br />Local resident Mark Haley discovered Cole's body riddled with slugs and buckshot, lying facedown in the road at about 3 o'clock that afternoon. Cole had been shot above the waist on his left side and in the head. Cole's team of horses apparently kept heading towards Rhodesville. <br /><br />At 8 pm Lauderdale County Sheriff OB Hill headed to the scene of the crime with bloodhounds from Tuscumbia, in Colbert County, and tracked one Anthony Agnew, 49 years old, to Koger Island, in the TN River; clues at Koger Island led Sheriff Hill to Baldwin, Mississippi, where, five days after the alleged murder, Agnew was captured on Sunday and remanded to jail. <br /><br />After a preliminary hearing before Justice McPeters Agnew was bound over to the grand jury without bail. He was tried in Florence in late March. <br /><br />Agnew was defended by RT Simpson, Jr. and George P. Jones, with WH Sawtelle and Cecil A. Beasley prosecuting. <br /><br />In the FOUR-DAY trial it was alleged that Agnew shot Cole because the married Cole was planning to run away with Agnew's wife, thus Agnew ambushed Cole from a blind along a wire fence on Waterloo Road, however the jury was hung, with six jurors voting "guilty" and six voting "not guilty."<br /><br />Agnew's second trial was held in September of 1902 and this time the jury found him "not guilty."<br /><br />Joseph "Joe" Cole (ca. 1861-1902), who had a "fair reputation" locally, was married to a woman named Bettie Cantrell (ca. 1862-1952) with two children. Joe was a farmer living at Gravelly Springs, near Rhodesville, in 1900.<br /><br />Oakland (near Rhodesville in Lauderdale County) resident and Baldwin, Mississippi native Anthony Agnew (ca. 1853-), said to be "a very superior negro" with an "excellent reputation," was married to a woman named Fannie and the couple had a total of 12 children, two of which had died by 1900.1. Newspapers.com2. Bell & Howell Micro Photo3. Newspapers.com4. Newspapers.com5. Newspapers.com6. Bell & Howell Micro Photo7. Newspapers.com8. Bell & Howell Micro Photo9. Newspapers.com10. Lauderdale County, Alabama Circuit Court11. Ancestry.com Library Edition12. Ancestry.com Library EditionLee Freeman1. 1902-01-172. 1901-01-243. 1902-01-244. 1902-01-315. 1902-01-316. 1902-03-287. 1902-04-048. 1902-09-269. 1902-09-2610. March Term, 1902.11. 1900-06-0412. 1900-06-08.Still ImagesJpeghttps://shoalsblackhistory.omeka.net/items/show/1256https://d1y502jg6fpugt.cloudfront.net/36745/archive/files/d353310fe3cb07a4845ce12eb0e546e7.jpg?Expires=1717027200&Signature=XEv5IqbrdfvNvKb243w00zXge0Yeicj41zcsjz7yMMyY5-K-db0PbizTCkDs0j43wdNJ45saPB80bX9gjyM2QmPwlC-ujTLK-f8RlRw25sGm1pFdAWnlpLU%7E3bXsyv45TN8i7vJ13w0fGwCm%7EzrcymPbDcP8X8fYgqPDLee-MBhI4H8MldDKmbMxwrKokK4d8-rjyTeOaxM85u%7E4WKmItkgk%7ENgPMENlgcfrhTx23IFtG3Jw77TzmQXFxue%7Eb7xokTmo1oW3-Y0vNJyg6dR%7Ec66Lp2AOpnhR5PuKOlnV3MSh3eBdrdhHX5Z6HzTmKomB2snwBD3%7Et2cYEAuqeI6JPw__&Key-Pair-Id=K6UGZS9ZTDSZMhttps://d1y502jg6fpugt.cloudfront.net/36745/archive/files/cd2e1f2de69036ed366c7b949e7068db.jpg?Expires=1717027200&Signature=r2bkcW8J7roWDNb%7EtBEIUAz4p6uH6M2Duf2cDrzXS%7EcmiNO%7E1DmZhLsS2RAPM3zoPdsFMYfHjmlmdlIkOlLmaF%7EM0KmnDiR419Tq2NhSNlLZZ%7EKM37bI1zAMkHz4Gx8o4pIFBZ8LuJ19RFCkpXvRVd2-o5P5Uh4GqVQYKkHtJnVQZqqk5lneOfa4MMouo38afLmlZ%7EJoK5YyAd7zlAOkuOT9ejrtXUL09p5uecYPx4vZK0-kltGhP3k6BwSYyPzP41-dvV-g8JB6U9v3s18GVgzEgcFKSX2Kf8RaUkLPFB4Kf0wWdbttMlf1JLQ8Mxw7NEhjsKwNVs6EfwVV5UYcjQ__&Key-Pair-Id=K6UGZS9ZTDSZMhttps://d1y502jg6fpugt.cloudfront.net/36745/archive/files/ff8e2c752cf0ff63565a1090eba8bf9c.jpg?Expires=1717027200&Signature=FMpncl0sXFs9%7EdTu1-01jbUIibfFq6mJ8tMwL8bcKP61DSeEw9XgYK1EvN0C9poKSQ2b6pt60bPY-ziGDqJR8vBci7yL74gQCBMSs08gveYBFsWlMqSk-iFkf3Z00mUjyAjeEDE6giuZka%7EOScY2P709lWcPaI0fOAH7Rgs-qVGO5o3OHTcfFpXQy3DX7r4gXprGW0qrpoLFviJdo6geYwp5gMPoIFdU%7E16DKZN%7E%7EovfOMR5gF5f4BLxzCGZz4pTdWhvpzwrX89QycErbF5%7E7OfZfWgJhejBzYlK4SeRBUWmFFhsdDxJd1fTnG9yCHiwFDwc4KpcdmWJytK116L2FQ__&Key-Pair-Id=K6UGZS9ZTDSZMhttps://d1y502jg6fpugt.cloudfront.net/36745/archive/files/4c8a41361eff4bbed882780614471bc3.jpg?Expires=1717027200&Signature=AFif%7Ei1Wqb83cgZZzuXXwNDz1o9XaAV9GFEaF02gB2Q7tfO60nirL5nRYC-glPr2HE8-tGapA29qf-ahw9CByJIcI%7ECeAU0mq96WFNfV0hmyJcNvFgqs9%7E9MCbhy0Y1f3QWhAZNlJmiPmaRL-0hPNuXjwBmlU6jKW0p2A1MjkjDNFtnwLYYH7YDqvHJKDQ1pglMQD23YzNRWGLgGUny84gDP%7EHrW7Z4HBRjvX3Z6-Otr0ixLFSf2FLn0Ncjzg9lf7qRiCbPBVQKotUfz%7EuPaOWr-s6lPsjsWFWe4AWUhWfheon657jiheq-mLyLRkKOu2r3Ea1OwMi9zYB1v-j-wRA__&Key-Pair-Id=K6UGZS9ZTDSZMhttps://d1y502jg6fpugt.cloudfront.net/36745/archive/files/97c0399ce8e306f191017acca4ec9293.jpg?Expires=1717027200&Signature=Z52M8tgZ4ZycP3nV76I6L25ODUTBGg7nO6oUTudkt9vJq03YIZRk8ljqVSLxTACwAAS3usE8BeASbjc30saeH-rZlE3tuaX7tbv9rbQ5hfnF-uFEcptr8-PxQyHmXa9IrPNKNfBoxi0tOGe9yy5bRUjIFb8zWci%7ENeAP8NqZ3lGrGMOCqz9F-lKJINMXohz10WMRTc85PSgHjfxJtpsvaD7FwXgUiAd5aOv7mm8k7Hwq0paERnanSCzx8yD-1mpTmbfc80MpqN2Ov4FkvvRXBoii2BF1jm%7ENxPWcUyJwFc4OL0t-6QEps92jM2hsJLVoZUIPEFRtESkC2KeIhyUebA__&Key-Pair-Id=K6UGZS9ZTDSZMhttps://d1y502jg6fpugt.cloudfront.net/36745/archive/files/11dbf908c8c103a8b96e4e0b7031ace3.jpg?Expires=1717027200&Signature=VSeLdqORfJfxn3W4TSz5Y8MpDqh3-9plkzeqnA63FEPwjH4aOfBibsBQBfui-kkDllAvEOg0lwHSQdGEAuIYXUJgHU1B0vTXqTJ6U2BsZ0XuMB03xNYQpE70GwPemi%7ECLqzD3GOlBi2dy2hs1XLihN15qePpbN3ddzMSQeu6eeTVlF9NeggK2GXcVk59Z7T0uLk5EQyYMVYVlykZwVLhN8-Bq2ETqVr77-8sMSrRprUPdbAJxFgCsuR4%7EHtY%7EjC92Y96%7EFfgrzIK8voqJJYa5B8wzRdbsA4HdBtEDYatSjEQMuUzeEV4tTXo5kCezZq58JKDeaFQE3YucQcxzuus0Q__&Key-Pair-Id=K6UGZS9ZTDSZMhttps://d1y502jg6fpugt.cloudfront.net/36745/archive/files/152643258f50b77dd525003bc7e46389.jpg?Expires=1717027200&Signature=a6-D02YSq9BwYDDfcTzVhQbH8P7o2Q6HAeuOskCK4hFnfhFXfx9yd-7Jr7CwH5tFwNY6bgifuebK8N2qlvS%7EHHUucIMGLfhq-AbNWzBssyZeRg5xdZAnbVJtn4yFhKox01Fel%7E1IaAZ8NoDtlIVYI5utelr8dMNEKXdVhgDDFqhuRWNAM6OK5z-4MG0YM4GLcbDcjW0X49rcD80ENmAPM2NOQELmYfy5czttJ0p4gfjoCTuUfsn2-QBBposjXazsV5TPgwggCJkPFwmq50wq3E9-XrwleIQylXhpzxInLBcPYAY3jR4mu2NKSr1qB0tXqIgTO8Zoo8fZpdyRtIvG-w__&Key-Pair-Id=K6UGZS9ZTDSZMhttps://d1y502jg6fpugt.cloudfront.net/36745/archive/files/9efa329159119a7000a41438bf4bfea1.jpg?Expires=1717027200&Signature=Qaax%7EZ9Sr%7EimtoK3G%7EOmnOfCkio1cZgOltAMOt1cnkPEbWKUTTtbUYgaspFhbghnSGsbw9LWO-ydLQSwpINrdpeDiHxJmTS7O3aEK0QqoChOsXG4sgPwWsdx3lIMaCZMmWilFEB87PqR3zwq7KAgsJevjeOIDU3koEjtU5q97vzwE3zahGrOF6RHTQivoqx0sQhWJd94G%7ENGujpmuTzNokb0hlIhtHHCBPhFDzaVwFFwzpcvlGoWR4LJl2Bt-eJYZ-fKD20O9AS8vv6Mu1mOa9U0jRhRqEdtj18ZdNGUYtc2lS6ufifjyVBHtnlbOiqC%7Ea42bMDUzHCiLQcpYeLCcg__&Key-Pair-Id=K6UGZS9ZTDSZMhttps://d1y502jg6fpugt.cloudfront.net/36745/archive/files/1a47848a2b3d40ca9971eb8b6b040224.jpg?Expires=1717027200&Signature=Yx4LRw%7E3bJrg0cyPuA1W5qrC3vGTRPxu%7E5AuA9oF3UjxJ92IfCqmIjaylmJ7lqJoeyEwUz%7EgUzFXze87vwsH8lLa-RvU1vaGC7utILoFavGNHVSPryb0Pxh00UdsrJ7Er0bzLM7NEgw3cbtsgrW20VgQrEeLp-trMQocg3ziTybBFfQBEh%7EA0Auv3JV2jaJ%7EQVV5tXR8ETfvztCgeruPc4ZB%7EuL-IPh3RqpG9ySbD0OpTS%7E2mmzPdbhmShfctq7LF6knyOKAJ72yrCOQSYpF0bzEWA-keBku1v1q-zt65fXcGhd0Xwadq%7E8iAZiuICCcmURLxqSOMVhn0%7EHx9Ze2jw__&Key-Pair-Id=K6UGZS9ZTDSZMhttps://d1y502jg6fpugt.cloudfront.net/36745/archive/files/39f99010071ee74cf15eb680d3a3437c.jpg?Expires=1717027200&Signature=nD2y55c9ctrz34%7ENq8B%7EkD-ihsDl9dolfP3UuEeCxt7FL-bBuAjmk8kBziEn2veBjuFYtAjG7ntmR9FMwSP9ELAFIINIjimPdRA-TIUdFSVjAOj-t0sYo97Au9N1MkWiZs7sU0aJp5j6XBwQtNdZvuhSmRApLCJ-vl6NYAylR5wxy%7EzDIgKmRzMKYsDUS4aYqSf4WXMO3dSppWLXXmxB2P8RGCip%7EfDYYcvgfdV-XwVa-mGtwcZxX94Ie6UzjCZfmdOZFSuu97ueJvLfhNeH0%7Exv%7Eyv3ZKWnRa%7EKT%7ERBYYQsNREmx70eecR9Mp3QlVbiDpeA6t-LtJ2DYOUnetLgpg__&Key-Pair-Id=K6UGZS9ZTDSZMhttps://d1y502jg6fpugt.cloudfront.net/36745/archive/files/e5a63d398d5febced97ef38c00dd3703.jpg?Expires=1717027200&Signature=LAChF1pYDJBxvRULhGg22P0HNvj3A9-zA4DbkZ6N225WSUaHnMarmvnaKxm2WbZRU8tfkTpkKhpU8n6eSkaIrMgRBe8sygoLb44hA7TaIoy6WGT7a%7EJyzbiqyBTqneYEPbOO5wE0CaGL%7EQSQsqyYBOJMoc2wLCHU2irpwepqG3kyTL3XJVY8Ti3XInfjtyF464gJfLbn-Hhyhu4A-7s3M0LqcX2ZWWC85t63EiV-AIb2WMv1CjzCO2r%7EW4p4bLP3QBjuEQo3BcWlL3UR-GFuLH5EBPcSxct3-4Ht4eSc5ujgtl0hpMvobIxc7R6322lWveg4i%7EuKwU4z4K0QCpy-gw__&Key-Pair-Id=K6UGZS9ZTDSZMhttps://d1y502jg6fpugt.cloudfront.net/36745/archive/files/1f2d7b002bc4306bdd6e9af2cbc5ed7f.jpg?Expires=1717027200&Signature=HqF8hpR4dsHyfwhyjFpEc3FFfox53k9ixBJ8YOvZjjTrzYuSaeENxdfTvDv1Jota5VotAT3lFSioP4rFIyGtBFat4OTmtnsk3%7EmDmO5Fr1CFZF%7EEza2pYUYSXgUjzsNEGdBfh1X8TWBqtPP%7Eh0HwMMmyL2-Zav1ryPmka3nvKrGMaHPkQjEC5CAKZ-CJbgN4GDIblWA2Rg1LiL4xHq%7EAglPan9EhuMv7VrGJEMeHnimdc4qbc-RsJxRx6py6Mf2S7po10np%7E4IbeHRVEwRb1Ji9Jz5dNqmrLQgaArqOkgpy9oC-2les43I5ygI1cEL0AuVqCWN3Tv4lDOl-h4qEqmg__&Key-Pair-Id=K6UGZS9ZTDSZM1. Florence Herald2. Florence Times3. Florence Herald4. Florence Herald5. Florence Herald6. Florence Times7. Florence Herald8. Florence Times9. Florence Herald10. Lauderdale County, Alabama Circuit Court11. Us Census, 1900 Lauderdale County, Alabama. 12. Us Census, 1900 Lauderdale County, Alabama. EnglishImages are available for educational and research purposes. This image may not be reproduced for commercial purposes without the express written consent of the copyright holder. It is the responsibility of the interested party to identify the copyright holder and receive permission.

Joe Cole Shot and Killed by Anthony Agnew

Similar Items